Sign in Subscribe

3. Understanding Protectors in Depth: The Guardian Parts of Our Inner System

Last updated on 
3. Understanding Protectors in Depth: The Guardian Parts of Our Inner System

This article explores protectors in detail, examining what they are, how they function through positive intent, and the crucial distinction between managers and firefighters.

What Are Protectors?

Protectors are parts that are trying to protect us from "stuff." This intentionally vague term reflects the reality that what protectors guard against varies significantly depending on each individual protector. However, their protective efforts generally fall into two broad categories.

Category One: Protection from Real-Life Situations

Protectors work to shield us from specific situations in real life. This might include:

  • Rejection: A protector might make us super nice so that nobody could ever reject us
  • Loss: We might try to take care of other people as well as we can to avoid losing them
  • Failure: We might work as hard as we can to prevent failure
  • Loneliness: We might do everything possible to avoid being alone in real life

These protectors work hard to avoid specific situations or things that could happen in the external world.

Category Two: Protection from Inner Pain

The second category involves protecting us from pain in our inner world. "Pain" here is intentionally general because the types of pain or burdens we carry can vary dramatically. Protectors in this category might:

  • Work to ensure certain exiles and their burdens don't surface
  • Prevent specific memories from being encountered again by avoiding certain situations
  • Block certain emotions from being felt because those emotions are associated with burdens and pain from the past
  • Keep specific somatic activation buried—bodily responses we've been carrying, often for decades after the original events

Protectors protect us from "stuff"—either situations that could happen in real life (so they do whatever necessary to avoid these) or pain residing in our inner world that they don't want us to feel or encounter again.

Protectors as Parts: Core Characteristics

In the previous exploration of parts, we established that parts are like little people with their own perspectives, motivations, beliefs, feelings, memories, and behaviors. Since protectors are parts, all these same characteristics apply to them.

Similarly, protectors can be activated (where we're influenced by them but maintain some distance between the protector and the Self) or blended (where they completely take us over). All the principles about parts in general apply equally to protectors.

Positive Intent: The Key to Understanding Protectors

One critically important element for understanding protectors is positive intent. This perspective holds that every single protector is trying to achieve something positive—through their own perspective—for our system.

In essence, the positive intent of protectors is what they're trying to protect us from. This might mean:

  • Avoiding specific situations: "I will never again be in that situation or feel like that"—their positive intent is ensuring we never feel that way again
  • Achieving specific situations: Being so nice, so helpful, so high-achieving that we're safe, meaning bad things don't happen to us again
  • Keeping emotions and memories exiled: Doing everything to keep emotions and memories down or out of awareness in the system so we don't feel them again

The positive intent of protectors is protecting us from specific "stuff"—whether external situations or internal pain.

Two Types of Protectors: Managers and Firefighters

Internal Family Systems distinguishes two types of protectors based on how they try to protect us from specific situations or feelings—two different strategies for guarding against emotions and burdens from the past: managers and firefighters.

Managers: Proactive Protectors

Managers are protectors that work proactively. A manager part will try to control our life—your life, my life—in such a way that specific bad situations don't show up and specific feelings aren't even touched.

We can understand managers as trying to avoid things through control. They attempt to control your life, your behaviors, your thoughts, your feelings in such a way that the things they're trying to avoid don't even appear. This might mean:

  • Working really hard so you're safe
  • Trying to keep everything together so emotions don't surface
  • Task-mastering: "do this, do this, do this, do this"
  • Being super nice and constantly pleasant to everybody to avoid getting into dangerous situations
  • Making yourself small or big to ensure you're proactively safe

Managers operate through preemptive control, organizing life to prevent triggers and threats before they arise.

Firefighters: Reactive Protectors

Firefighters represent the total opposite. Where managers are proactive, firefighters are reactive.

Firefighters, like firefighters in real life, come up when there's a fire—when a burden and exile are coming up, when a feeling or emotion is suddenly being felt again. They will do whatever they have to, and just as in a burning house where the water often produces more damage than the fire itself, firefighters will do whatever it takes to get away from that feeling. This might include:

  • Binge-watching TV
  • Zoning out
  • Dissociative behavior
  • Eating so much that you don't feel anymore
  • Taking any type of drug to escape whatever feeling has emerged from underneath

Firefighters respond to the immediate crisis: "Oh, I'm feeling something I don't want to feel—watch TV for five hours and zone out."

The System Organized Around Exiles

When we understand managers as trying to control our lives and firefighters as ensuring that once an exile or certain burden or pain has been touched it doesn't fully emerge, we can see how our inner world is fundamentally organized around our exiles.

Our protectors—both managers and firefighters—arrange themselves in relation to exiles:

  • Managers try to avoid specific situations so that exiles don't get triggered, or they work to achieve certain things in life to ensure certain experiences don't happen again
  • Firefighters constantly watch for the exiles and their pain, working to keep them suppressed

We can visualize the inner system as having specific exiles (different ones for each person), and around these exiles our system has intelligently built defensive strategies and protective strategies. These strategies developed because they were the best way of dealing with pain we couldn't digest in our lives—they enable us to navigate life with this vulnerability in our system.

The system is organized around exiles. We have multiple configurations where similar setups exist—exiles surrounded by protectors, managers, and firefighters. These might show completely different burdens and completely different strategies, but the same underlying principle applies: protectors organizing themselves around exiles.

Protectors Are Not Their Roles

A crucial principle to understand is that protectors are not their roles. Parts do certain things—zoning out, working really hard—but they are not the same as those behaviors. Parts use these behaviors trying to ensure we stay safe, avoid exiles, and avoid dangerous situations.

Even though parts fulfill their roles, they often don't want to. If parts could choose—and this becomes a critical element of the therapeutic aspect of IFS—if protectors could choose, they would often love to do different things or do what they do differently.

They're doing what they do because they had to. They often think they still have to. Maybe some do, but oftentimes we can find different solutions. They're doing it because they had to and think they have to, but they often don't want to.

This recognition—that protectors are trapped in roles they didn't choose and often don't desire—represents a powerful place where we can create change within the IFS model. Understanding that parts are separate from their behaviors and that they carry positive intent even while performing unwanted roles opens the door to transformation and healing.

Conclusion

Protectors work tirelessly to shield us from external situations and internal pain. Every protector operates from positive intent, attempting to keep us safe according to its understanding. Managers work proactively through control, organizing life to prevent triggers before they occur. Firefighters work reactively, deploying emergency measures when exiles threaten to surface.

The entire protective system organizes itself around exiles—the vulnerable parts carrying undigested pain from the past. Protectors aren't their roles; they're parts trapped in strategies they developed when we needed protection but that they would often gladly relinquish if better options existed.

This understanding forms the foundation for the transformative work possible in IFS: recognizing that protectors want relief from their burdens just as much as we want relief from our symptoms, and that by working with them rather than against them, genuine healing becomes possible.

Sources

Glossary